Good Cop/Bad Cop Parenting

by James Lehman, MSW

If you and your spouse take opposing roles in dealing with your kids, you’re not alone. Many parents take on the roles of “good cop” and “bad cop” in the family. For instance, Dad is the kid’s best buddy, and mom is the nag. Or dad is strict and mom is a sympathizer.

Which “cop” is right? And should you be a cop at all?

I see two problems with the notion of good cop/bad cop parenting. First, is the very idea that somebody has to be a “cop” all the time. Parents don’t need to be cops. They simply need to be coaches and teachers for their children.

Second, what’s really happening when parents become good cops and bad cops is that the kids have learned to split their parents. The area of the split is where kids go to get out of meeting their responsibilities.

For example, Tommy goes to mom and says, “Dad’s making me clean my room before we go to the mall.” Or he says to mom, “Why do I have to clean my room? Dad doesn’t make me do it.” When your child makes complaints like this, both parents have to be supportive of each other. You have to be able to say, “These are the rules Dad and I both have, and you have to do it or you’re going to be held responsible for the consequences.” Then turn around and walk away. That’s it. Give simple statements of support. The more unified you are as parents, the more likely your child is to complete his responsibilities, because he doesn’t have another way out. The only way out is to act responsibly and do what’s asked of him.

But what if you don’t really agree with what Dad is asking Tommy to do? If you have a problem with a rule or limit your spouse sets or a request that’s being made of your kid, don’t make a face. Don’t sigh. And, by all means, don’t argue with your spouse about the issue in front of the child…or even indicate that you are going to argue. Just tell your child he has to do what’s been asked of him. Then talk with your spouse later, after the kids have gone to bed and out of earshot. This is important, because kids pick up on non-verbal cues from their parents a lot more than you think. If your child sees that you disagree with what’s being asked of him, he’ll bring up the issue again and again, to split you and your spouse and to avoid meeting the responsibility.

Simple statements of support work when you use them consistently. When Tommy complains that Dad won’t let him play Runescape before he does his homework, and you say, “Your father said you can’t play Runescape until you do your homework. That’s the rule,” you can bet Tommy will stop trying to split you and your spouse.

James Lehman, MSW was a renowned child behavioral therapist who worked with struggling teens and children for three decades. He created the Total Transformation Program to help people parent more effectively. James’ foremost goal was to help kids and to “empower parents.”

Related articles

• Uninvolved Parenting – Psychology Definition of the Week (psychology.about.com)
• Risque Photo Shoot for Teen Daughter, Mom Is Worried and Gets Excellent Advice on the Forum (parentingteens.about.com)
• Quest for Perfection in Parenthood Leads to Stress (psychcentral.com)
• Aunting & Uncling Essentials: Third-party Perspectives (psychologytoday.com)
• When Parents Make Children Their Friend or Spouse (pt5.psychologytoday.com)
• Do I Wanna Be a Dad? Things to Consider in Making This Huge Life Decision. (psychologytoday.com)
• My dad resorts to violence (psychcentral.com)
• When parents disagree about their adolescent (psychologytoday.com)
• Seeking to be the ‘perfect parent’ not always good for new moms and dads (sciencedaily.com)
• Good Cop, Bad Cop (lexiconlover.wordpress.com)

Originally posted 2011-12-14 12:20:55.